Vote Cinches Robust Regional Response to Sea Level Rise
On December 5, a sprint was over; a marathon began. The Bay Conservation and Development Commission unanimously adopted its Regional Shoreline Adaptation Plan, meeting a state deadline and shifting the pressure to local governments that must now write “subregional” plans for dealing with sea level rise. These are due at the end of 2033: a distant due date in the face of global change, but maybe a quick one considering the complexity of the task.
After RSAP’s first release in September, there was push and there was pull. Local governments and others objected to some of the mandatory standards proposed, calling for “flexibility.” A November draft tacked in that direction, changing quite a few “musts” to “shoulds” and demoting some of the Standards to “planning tips.” Now it was the turn of the environmental coalition, some forty groups, to decry a “watering-down.” Further redrafting ensued.
The result of these contending pressures seems, surprisingly, to please nearly everyone nearly well enough. “We seem to have found the sweet spot,” says BCDC planning director Jessica Fain. The Sierra Club’s Gita Dev agrees: “We are very happy with the results of the RSAP. Now,” she goes on, “it’s time to get serious about execution.”
Local governments are clamoring for support for this new task. BCDC is devising a technical assistance program. With passage of November’s Proposition 4, the Ocean Protection Council will have more funds to grant. To ease the burden and clarify the options, counties and cities around the Bay are looking at doing combined, multi-jurisdictional shoreline plans.
Diagram of how adaptation pathways can unfold. From Werners et al, Environmental Science & Policy
BCDC is also pondering another trip to Sacramento. Under last year’s SB 272, which started this planning ball rolling, the agency can only advise about the plans being prepared — until the moment when they are completed. Then the bay regulators can say “Yes” or “No,” but the sole result of a “No” is that a city or county drops down the priority list for state funding. “The Legislature has taken us halfway,” BCDC executive director Larry Goldzband remarked last summer. Should the agency now seek a stronger hand? “We are planning to lean into that question in 2025,” says Fain.
Top Photo: King tide in Alameda in November 2024 by Maurice Ramirez
Other Recent Posts
Your Nine-County Guide to Bay Area Storm Prep
KneeDeep has you covered with this nine-county list of resources available in case of storm-related emergencies this winter.
Check Your Project Status: It’s All Here
The Bay Adapt Project and Funding Navigator is a first-of-its-kind, one-stop shop where everyone can find project statuses and funding ideas.
A Man Who Wears Many Hats
The leader of the San Mateo RCD’s Forest Health and Fire program says his mantra is to “be open to being wrong.”
Solano Samples Air And Finds Dirt
After helping shut down a polluting Vallejo cement plant, residents are working to expand community-led air quality monitoring across Solano County.
Who’s In Charge? What Projects Make the Cut?
The region has made progress planning for sea level rise, but who will coordinate a $100 billion effort over the coming decades remains an open question.
Could We Be Building Highways 15 Feet Above Ground Sometime Soon?
The agency is grappling with how to protect highways, public transit, and biking and walking paths from the rising waters of the coming century.
A Bulwark for San Francisco’s Skyscrapers?
A new joint federal and local plan maps out 13 strategies to protect 7.5 miles of San Francisco’s waterfront from sea level rise and future flooding.



